Paramount’s “Illusory” Offer Falls Flat as Warner Bros. Discovery Doubles Down on Netflix Deal

Warner Bros. Discovery’s board didn’t just say no to Paramount’s $108 billion takeover attempt. It issued a blistering letter calling the offer “illusory,” “misleading,” and “high-risk.” This wasn’t a polite pass. It was a takedown.

Here’s what’s really going on beneath the drama and why this story is far from over.

Paramount’s $30 per share all-cash tender offer looked better on paper than Netflix’s $27.75 per share bid. But Warner Bros. Discovery says that’s where the advantages end. According to the board, Paramount’s proposal lacks real financing, hinges on a revocable trust, carries significant regulatory and execution risk, and could result in billions in termination and financing costs if accepted.

The most fundamental issue is that Paramount doesn’t have secured financing. Despite public claims, the board says there is no binding equity commitment from Larry Ellison or the Ellison family. Instead, the equity funding relies on a revocable trust, which the board says is not transparent, not enforceable, and not a substitute for a secured obligation from a controlling shareholder. Making matters worse, the trust’s liability is capped at just 7 percent of its $40.65 billion commitment, roughly $2.8 billion, even in the event of willful breach.

Warner Bros. Discovery also highlighted concerns about the offer’s regulatory profile. Paramount’s bid was backed by sovereign wealth funds from the Middle East and by Jared Kushner’s investment firm, Affinity Partners. While Kushner’s firm has since backed out, the board noted that this ownership structure could still raise red flags with U.S. national security regulators. Paramount’s claim that the Ellison family and RedBird Capital would backstop the full financing remains unsupported by public documentation.

Beyond financing, the structure of the offer itself is a problem. The Paramount offer is not binding. It can be amended or withdrawn at any time and would not even clear regulatory timelines before its stated expiration. Warner Bros. Discovery called it exactly what it is: illusory.

In contrast, the Netflix deal has been signed, structured, and backed by enforceable financing. Under the terms of that agreement, Netflix would acquire Warner Bros. Discovery’s studios, HBO, and HBO Max for $27.75 per share, comprised of $23.25 in cash and $4.50 in Netflix stock. WBD shareholders would also retain exposure to the company’s legacy cable networks through the planned 2026 spin-off of Discovery Global. Add in Netflix’s $5.8 billion break fee if the deal falls through, compared to Paramount’s $5 billion, and the certainty of execution becomes a major differentiator.

Netflix co-CEOs Ted Sarandos and Greg Peters have both publicly endorsed the deal, emphasizing its pro-consumer, pro-creator, and pro-growth implications. Sarandos called it the best outcome for stockholders and creators alike.

Paramount, for its part, has said it will continue pitching its offer directly to shareholders. But it also appears unwilling, at least for now, to improve its bid. Unless it comes back with a materially higher offer, likely north of $32 per share, and ironclad financing, it’s hard to see a path forward.

The future of TNT Sports, Discovery Global, and the rest of Warner’s cable portfolio now hinges on whether the Netflix merger clears regulatory review. But unless something major changes in Paramount’s proposal, the outcome seems increasingly settled.