SiriusXM has hired Tubi CEO Anjali Sud to pursue digital growth as Pandora loses listeners and advertising revenue increasingly comes from properties SiriusXM doesn’t own. The company’s off-platform advertising business now appears to generate more revenue than Pandora’s own advertising operation, while its subscription-led segment produces roughly 85% of gross profit.
Sud becomes CEO on January 1, 2027, succeeding Jennifer Witz, who steps down December 31 and will remain an adviser through 2027.
The appointment puts an executive who built a profitable free-streaming business in charge of 33 million SiriusXM subscribers, $1.5 billion in quarterly subscription revenue and an advertising network whose expanding reach has yet to produce meaningful companywide growth.
Off-Platform Pulls Ahead
Pandora ended September with 38.8 million monthly active users, down 7% year over year. Ad-supported listening hours declined 10% to 2.25 billion, and self-pay subscribers fell 3% to 5.5 million.
Pandora and Off-Platform advertising revenue still increased 1% to $419 million.
SiriusXM’s operating disclosures indicate that the growth is coming from outside Pandora.
The company reported $91.63 in advertising revenue per thousand Pandora listener hours during the third quarter. Applying that yield to its reported listening hours produces approximately $206 million in advertising revenue attributable to Pandora’s own service, down from roughly $228 million a year earlier.
Subtracting that estimate from the segment’s $419 million in advertising revenue leaves approximately $213 million generated through AdsWizz and other off-platform activity, compared with about $188 million last year.
Those figures are calculated from SiriusXM’s disclosed metrics rather than a separately reported revenue breakdown.
Off-platform advertising appears to have overtaken Pandora’s own advertising revenue for the quarter. Growth from podcasts, programmatic advertising and technology fees offset declining monetization on Pandora’s service.
SiriusXM can sell more advertising even as fewer people listen to its owned music-streaming product. Its ability to continue growing that business increasingly depends on advertising inventory, creator relationships and distribution arrangements outside Pandora.
The 85% Profit Center
SiriusXM’s flagship service ended September with 32.9 million subscribers, including 31.3 million classified as self-pay.
The SiriusXM segment generated $1.60 billion in quarterly revenue, including $1.50 billion from subscriptions. Gross profit reached $963 million, producing a 60% margin.
Pandora and Off-Platform generated $549 million in revenue and $173 million in gross profit at a 32% margin.
The core SiriusXM segment therefore accounted for approximately 85% of the gross profit produced by the company’s two businesses.
Those economics explain why subscription retention remains central to SiriusXM’s financial performance.
Companywide third-quarter revenue slipped slightly to $2.153 billion. Adjusted EBITDA increased 3% to $694 million, and free cash flow rose 14% to $293 million.
Lower programming expenses, customer-care automation and reduced marketing spending helped offset stagnant revenue.
Sud inherits a profitable business with limited organic subscriber growth. Expanding advertising can improve the revenue mix, although the company’s existing segment margins provide no assurance that new digital revenue will generate the same gross-profit contribution as subscriptions.
Free Counts as Paid
SiriusXM added just 5,000 net self-pay subscribers during the third quarter. That figure included 107,000 incremental Companion subscriptions, which qualifying full-price customers can activate for another household member without paying an additional subscription fee.
Excluding those complimentary accounts, all other self-pay activity combined produced approximately 102,000 net losses.
The Companion program has already offset substantial underlying subscriber losses while giving paying households another reason to maintain their subscriptions.
SiriusXM counts qualifying registered Companion users as self-pay subscribers, allowing one paying household to support multiple reported subscribers without generating another full-price payment.
Monthly churn improved to 1.5%, while average revenue per user held at $15.18.
Companion access can strengthen retention by making the household subscription more useful. It can also displace individual subscriptions that household members might otherwise purchase.
SiriusXM hasn’t disclosed the incremental revenue preserved through Companion retention or the amount of potential subscription revenue displaced by complimentary access.
Sud will inherit those tradeoffs as the company evaluates pricing, app access and additional free-listening opportunities. Expanding the number of registered listeners can support engagement and advertising inventory, but reported subscriber additions alone won’t establish whether those changes improve subscription revenue.
Reach Without Control
SiriusXM Media claims its advertising network now reaches approximately 255 million unduplicated monthly listeners, up from 170 million a year earlier.
The expansion includes YouTube Audio, where SiriusXM serves as the exclusive audio advertising representative in the United States. AdsWizz supplies advertising technology across third-party audio publishers and podcast properties.
That reach is considerably larger than the audience using SiriusXM’s owned services.
SiriusXM can earn advertising revenue and technology fees across outside listening environments without acquiring every listener directly. Those partners retain important control over distribution, discovery, engagement and access to users.
Sud comes from a business built around a different level of ownership.
Under her leadership, Tubi grew beyond 110 million monthly active users and became profitable. Its free streaming service controls the consumer experience, content discovery and advertising opportunities generated within its product.
Sud leaves Tubi as Fox begins integrating the service into its newly acquired Roku business. Fox’s $22 billion acquisition gives it control of a connected-TV operating system reaching more than 100 million households worldwide.
SiriusXM owns satellite infrastructure and maintains valuable automotive relationships, giving it established distribution inside the car. Its digital advertising expansion increasingly extends through services and publishers it doesn’t control.
Sud’s experience building an owned streaming audience becomes particularly relevant as SiriusXM weighs investment in Pandora’s declining listener base against advertising growth across outside properties.
Exclusivity Gets Expensive
SiriusXM has already started distributing more of its programming beyond its subscription service.
In June, SiriusXM signed a nonexclusive video podcast agreement with Tubi covering shows including Conan O’Brien Needs a Friend, Rotten Mango and What Now? with Trevor Noah.
The companies share advertising sales for the programming distributed on Tubi.
Sud was running Tubi when the agreement was signed. She now moves to SiriusXM, where the same type of arrangement introduces questions about licensing economics, advertising revenue and the commercial value of the underlying creator relationships.
Howard Stern’s expanded distribution provides another model.
SiriusXM retains the exclusive live show and extensive archive while HBO Max distributes adapted video episodes several days after the live broadcast.
The company preserves subscription-exclusive programming while gaining additional distribution for one of its most valuable personalities.
Podcasts can follow a broader distribution strategy because the content generates advertising revenue across services. Premium live programming can support subscriber retention through exclusivity.
The economics depend on content costs, rights ownership, licensing revenue, advertising yield and the subscription value of programming kept behind a paywall.
Sud will need to evaluate those returns when deciding which shows remain exclusive, which creators receive additional distribution and how much revenue SiriusXM retains from outside licensing and advertising agreements.
The Streaming Wars Take
Pandora’s declining listening hours make SiriusXM’s capital allocation increasingly consequential.
Investing in Pandora as a consumer destination requires spending on listener acquisition, retention, product development and content. Expanding off-platform advertising can generate additional revenue through existing publisher audiences, but introduces revenue-sharing costs and dependence on distribution partners.
SiriusXM doesn’t separately disclose gross-profit contributions from Pandora’s owned listening operation and its off-platform advertising activities. The combined segment’s 32% margin therefore provides limited visibility into which business produces the stronger incremental return.
That leaves Sud with a consequential allocation decision.
She can invest more heavily in rebuilding Pandora’s audience, direct additional resources toward AdsWizz and third-party advertising, or use free access and creator programming to connect the two businesses more closely.
The financial case for each option depends on incremental gross profit, content expenses, customer acquisition costs and the revenue SiriusXM retains after paying publishers and rights holders.
Subscription pricing carries a separate constraint. Broader access can improve household retention and attract new listeners, but giving paying customers comparable programming for free can reduce the revenue generated by existing relationships.
SiriusXM’s strongest evidence of progress will come from growth in advertising contribution after partner payments, improved Pandora engagement and continued retention of full-price paying households.
Sud inherits enough cash flow to invest in digital expansion. The decision that will define her tenure is how much of that capital goes toward rebuilding an owned audience and how much goes toward monetizing listeners SiriusXM may never own.
The Streaming Wars is intentionally ad-free
We don’t run display ads. Not because we can’t, but because we don’t believe in them.
They interrupt the reading experience. They cheapen the work. And they burn advertisers’ money on impressions nobody actually wants.
So we chose a different model.
We say the things people in this industry are already thinking but don’t say out loud. We connect the dots beyond the headline and focus on explaining why things matter to the people working in this business.
If you believe industry coverage can exist without clutter and interruption, you can support it here → SUPPORT TSW.
Support is optional. But it directly funds research and continued coverage — and helps prove this model can work.
Support TSW →
